Introduction
Recently the Magic community was mostly upset about the state of the current Standard after the ban of 《Field of the Dead》. It turns out that the other “best deck” in the Golos Standard (Goose-Oko-Nissa-Krasis shell) is even more dominant now than what Golos was before. However, I have a glimmer of positivism in this aspect and I will explain in this article why playing 《Oko, Thief of Crowns》 is not the only option if you want to win in this format. What I don’t really love about the format is how the Oko decks are centered in mana acceleration into planeswalkers, and a lot of games if you don’t answer the planeswalkers right away they will keep increasing their advantage to a point of no return.
However, Standard is usually a very dynamic format, and the best deck for a given time is usually not the best deck afterwards because people will target it more. So, the way to gain an advantage is to be a step ahead of what most of the people will play.
For example: When Golos was banned, the “best decks” left were Bant and Simic Food. A lot of people anticipated this move and decided to add black to the Simic deck for maindeck 《Noxious Grasp》 and 《Vraska, Golgari Queen》. But once this became the most popular deck there were basically two paths to try to gain an advantage. One is to go back and play a deck that isn’t targeted by 《Noxious Grasp》 (Temur Reclamation, Rakdos Sacrifice, Azorius Control) or go even further leveling the Sultai Food metagame maindecking 《Veil of Summer》:
Veil main is even more correct than 《Noxious Grasp》. 16/16 MCQ qualifying decks are hit by Veil.
— crokeyz (@crokeyz) October 29, 2019
Been testing 2 Veil/4 Grasp and holding Top 10 most of the day. Beginning to think 3/3 split may be correct.
This is madness.https://t.co/TYtSfhB6Pd@ArenaDecklists pic.twitter.com/IcpwQx0yIl
Now, if some people are succeeding with Noxius and also Veil maindeck, then the strategies that don’t get touched by these cards (I’ve seen some Rakdos Knights decks appearing lately on Magic Online) will start to be real even though their power level is lower than Oko-Nissa-Krasis.
And what would this lead us to? Stage one! If the metagame starts leveling a lot, there will come a point where the predators of week one decks will be diminished and week one decks will start to pop up again. That would be a more tempo-oriented version of Simic Food for example.
So, let’s review some decklists that I liked from the last weeks sorting them by leveling.
Metagame: Stage 1
For Stage one I will choose the Simic decklist that Shouta Yasooka used to win his MPL Split.
5 《Island》
4 《Breeding Pool》
3 《Temple of Mystery》
2 《Mobilized District》
-Land (24)- 4 《Gilded Goose》
4 《Paradise Druid》
4 《Hydroid Krasis》
4 《Brazen Borrower》
4 《Wicked Wolf》
2 《Questing Beast》
-Creature (22)-
2 《Once Upon a Time》
4 《Oko, Thief of Crowns》
4 《Nissa, Who Shakes the World》
-Spell (14)-
3 《Veil of Summer》
2 《Voracious Hydra》
2 《Negate》
2 《Mystical Dispute》
1 《Questing Beast》
1 《Disdainful Stroke》
-Sideboard (15)-
This is obviously very similar to any Sultai Food deck, so winrates shouldn’t differ a lot by playing this or Sultai. This deck will expect that some players choose to play fringe strategies such as Rakdos Sacrifice (hoping for 《Noxious Grasp》s in your opponent’s maindecks) while also having a less painful manabase against Knights and Gruul decks.
Also it’s nice to point out that 《Veil of Summer》 doesn’t interact with 《Aether Gust》 when you chose to use it as a 《Memory Lapse》, because it’s not countering the spell.
Metagame: Stage 2
Stage Two would be adding black for 《Noxious Grasp》 and 《Vraska, Golgari Queen》, as most of the MPL players of this split chose to do:
2 《Swamp》
1 《Island》
4 《Breeding Pool》
4 《Overgrown Tomb》
4 《Watery Grave》
3 《Fabled Passage》
-Land (25)- 4 《Gilded Goose》
4 《Paradise Druid》
4 《Hydroid Krasis》
4 《Wicked Wolf》
-Creature (16)-
4 《Once Upon a Time》
4 《Oko, Thief of Crowns》
2 《Vraska, Golgari Queen》
4 《Nissa, Who Shakes the World》
1 《Liliana, Dreadhorde General》
-Spell (19)-
2 《Thrashing Brontodon》
2 《Massacre Girl》
2 《Duress》
2 《Assassin’s Trophy》
2 《Legion’s End》
2 《Negate》
-Sideboard (15)-
This is what Matthew Nass and Paulo Vitor Damo da Rosa played with, and I liked it because they even tuned it for the mirror, replacing 《Garruk, Cursed Huntsman》 with 《Liliana, Dreadhorde General》 to not get your top end targeted by 《Noxious Grasp》. It even has 《Assassin’s Trophy》 in the sideboard in case your opponent is also playing Liliana.
This deck is what I consider to be the strongest strategy of the format in itself. And no matter how much it can get targeted it’s hard to imagine the winrate going low. Even though in the MPL Split Simic Food won I think playing black should give you a little edge for this matchup.
Metagame: Stage 3
For stage 3 I’d like to point out two decks that I really liked from the MCQW:
Temur Reclamation
First of all is the one my friend Matias Leveratto chose to play, coming a win short to making it again to the Arena MC:
2 《Mountain》
1 《Forest》
4 《Breeding Pool》
4 《Steam Vents》
4 《Stomping Ground》
3 《Fabled Passage》
3 《Temple of Mystery》
2 《Temple of Epiphany》
1 《Castle Vantress》
-Land (26)- 3 《Bonecrusher Giant》
2 《Brazen Borrower》
-Creature (5)-
4 《Growth Spiral》
3 《Aether Gust》
3 《Mystical Dispute》
2 《Flame Sweep》
3 《Chemister’s Insight》
2 《Escape to the Wilds》
4 《Expansion/Explosion》
4 《Wilderness Reclamation》
1 《Narset, Parter of Veils》
-Spell (29)-
3 《Veil of Summer》
2 《Niv-Mizzet, Parun》
2 《Lava Coil》
2 《Negate》
2 《Flame Sweep》
1 《Aether Gust》
-Sideboard (15)-
This strategy can be a little weak to aggro strategies, but in these Oko days there aren’t many Mono-Reds, Knights or Gruuls. Adding some 《Noxious Grasp》s in your opponent’s maindeck makes this deck can be very strong.
Shouta’s Simic decklist can be very problematic though. Bouncing 《Wilderness Reclamation》 before it triggers with 《Brazen Borrower》 into 《Nissa, Who Shakes the World》 could be impossible to overcome.
Rakdos Sacrifice
Let’s move to the deck that Antonino De Rosa used in the MCQW to earn a qualification for MC VII.
6 《Swamp》
4 《Blood Crypt》
4 《Fabled Passage》
3 《Castle Locthwain》
-Land (24)- 4 《Cauldron Familiar》
3 《Gutterbones》
4 《Priest of Forgotten Gods》
4 《Mayhem Devil》
4 《Midnight Reaper》
2 《Cavalier of Night》
-Creature (21)-
3 《Angrath’s Rampage》
2 《Noxious Grasp》
4 《Witch’s Oven》
2 《Chandra, Acolyte of Flame》
-Spell (15)-
4 《Duress》
2 《Embereth Shieldbreaker》
2 《Noxious Grasp》
2 《Mask of Immolation》
1 《Chandra, Acolyte of Flame》
-Sideboard (15)-
I’ve played with this deck a little bit and it’s very interesting how it can do crazy stuff (mostly with the combination of 《Claim the Firstborn》 with 《Priest of Forgotten Gods》) but it can be a little disfunctional from times to time since it’s very synergy-based.
The combination of 《Witch’s Oven》 with the 《Cauldron Familiar》 is really strong, and totally insane if you also add 《Midnight Reaper》 or 《Mayhem Devil》 to the mix. Sometimes you can even be super mana screwed but if you have one or two Ovens with the Cat you will just chumpblock and drain your opponent to death. My guess would be that the perfect hand is 1 Cat 4 Ovens 2 Lands. I can’t imagine ever losing with that.
Golgari Adventures
Lastly, I’d like to mention what the better performing Challenger so far this year, Chris Kvartek used to qualify (again!!!) in the MCQW.
6 《Forest》
4 《Overgrown Tomb》
1 《Fabled Passage》
4 《Temple of Malady》
2 《Castle Locthwain》
-Land (24)- 4 《Edgewall Innkeeper》
4 《Foulmire Knight》
3 《Paradise Druid》
2 《Order of Midnight》
4 《Lovestruck Beast》
4 《Murderous Rider》
3 《Rankle, Master of Pranks》
1 《Massacre Girl》
-Creature (25)-
2 《Find/Finality》
3 《Vraska, Golgari Queen》
2 《Liliana, Dreadhorde General》
-Spell (11)-
4 《Veil of Summer》
2 《Voracious Hydra》
2 《Massacre Girl》
2 《Legion’s End》
1 《Cavalier of Night》
-Sideboard (15)-
This Golgari Adventures deck is designed to not suffer much against 《Noxious Grasp》 (no more 《Questing Beast》s and 《Vivien, Arkbow Ranger》s, they are very good but you don’t want to trade down on mana in this format).
Instead he decided to run 3 《Rankle, Master of Pranks》 to even discard his own maindeck playset of 《Noxious Grasp》 in case they are useless (also making opponent to sacrifice a creature when you have the Human token provided by 《Lovestruck Beast》 is usually great). Notice 2 《Liliana, Dreadhorde General》 as a very strong top end to fight the Sultai Decks, very hard to kill for them.
Two GP Results and Conclusion
After seeing the results of GP Lyon and Nagoya, Oko decks were pretty dominant.
5 《Island》
4 《Breeding Pool》
4 《Hallowed Fountain》
4 《Temple Garden》
2 《Castle Vantress》
-Land (25)- 4 《Gilded Goose》
4 《Paradise Druid》
3 《Hydroid Krasis》
4 《Wicked Wolf》
-Creature (15)-
3 《Aether Gust》
2 《Growth Spiral》
3 《Mass Manipulation》
4 《Oko, Thief of Crowns》
4 《Nissa, Who Shakes the World》
-Spell (20)-
3 《Thrashing Brontodon》
3 《Teferi, Time Raveler》
2 《Veil of Summer》
2 《Negate》
1 《Mystical Dispute》
-Sideboard (15)-
In Lyon there were two copies of Bant Food with 3 《Mass Manipulation》 maindeck and 《Teferi, Time Raveler》 in the sideboard as a 《Veil of Summer》 protection, and one of them won the whole tournament in hands of Antoine Lagarde. An interesting approach of how to go over the top of other Oko Decks.
6 《Island》
4 《Breeding Pool》
2 《Temple of Mystery》
2 《Mobilized District》
-Land (25)- 4 《Gilded Goose》
4 《Paradise Druid》
4 《Hydroid Krasis》
4 《Brazen Borrower》
4 《Wicked Wolf》
-Creature (20)-
3 《Aether Gust》
4 《Oko, Thief of Crowns》
4 《Nissa, Who Shakes the World》
-Spell (15)-
3 《Veil of Summer》
2 《Kraul Harpooner》
2 《Disdainful Stroke》
2 《Mystical Dispute》
1 《Thrashing Brontodon》
1 《Aether Gust》
1 《Negate》
-Sideboard (15)-
In Nagoya Riku Kumagai won the tournament with the same Simic shell but instead of going over the top with 《Mass Manipulation》 it focused on the tempo fight with 4 《Brazen Borrower》, similar to what Shouta Yasooka did winning his MPL split.
That’s all for today, even though I’m not giving you a clean answer on what decks are good and which ones aren’t, I think it’s great that there isn’t a clear answer. Sure, Sultai Food is great, but it’s not unbeatable and people hating it too much will make the metagame more diverse with other strategies taking an advantage on that.
Sebastian Pozzo (Twitter)