Today, we will draft with the new set: Rivals of Ixalan!
I simulate the 8 first pick of a draft and asked to 4 Hareruya Pros Players what they would pick.
Here are the 4 gentlemen who accepted to participate in this experience:
You can see their profiles, more in details, here: Hareruya Pros.
It will be interesting to see if they will do the same choices or not.
PICK 1
Petr Sochurek
Pick
Earlier in the format I would have taken the and I am still not sure if it’s not the right pick, because the upside is really high
(its great if you get one of the dinosaurs that work well with it), but can easily not end up in your deck even if you are red and is a great card,
that is also easily splashable.
Sebastian Pozzo
Pick
would be my pick. Super stacked pack, other options I would consider are , which is great in decks, I also like a lot the in vampire decks, and is obviously very good in a dinosaur deck or any deck with . However I rather take an easy to splash removal, that helps with ascend and also fits aggro decks.
Kenji Tsumura
Pick
If you are looking for card power, , , are your 3 choices.
may be strong or weak depending on what you search for. Different from the release of this set, this card has lowered its value. Comparing and , it is simply that is strong, and white is better to pick than green so I pick .
Oliver Polak-Rottmann
Pick
. This pick is pretty straightforward for me. It is a removal and the other options are rather weak. would probably be my second choice.
Player’s Choice:
PICK 2
Petr Sochurek
Pick
I think that is the best uncommon and also a card that is better than most of the rares – it immediately replaces itself and
it snowballs extremely quickly if they don’t have answer for it.
Sebastian Pozzo
Pick
Even though is the best card to me I rather go for a second that is more likely to end up in my deck, so we are more open to different strategies and colors.
Kenji Tsumura
Pick
It was a tough pick betweenwhich is a card that I love. Though when you compare these two with their card power, I believe there is no big difference with and I can send a signal that I am on white, which makes me pick .
Oliver Polak-Rottmann
Pick
are also great in multiples but here would also be a great option in .
Player’s Choice:
PICK 3
Petr Sochurek
Pick
This pick is tough and nothing really stands out to me, but is the best card in my opinion so I think I would just take that.
Sebastian Pozzo
Pick
Now we get a very weak pack. , and are slightly better than the I think. However, once again I rather stay in colour, and try to work through the ascend mechanic since I already have 2 .
Kenji Tsumura
Pick
This pack has no cards in white. It would’ve been great if there were cards that could’ve drifted me to a different color worth picking, but none of that also. If we become a UW deck, I will pick a card that will be useful, which is .
Oliver Polak-Rottmann
Pick
This pack is rather weak again but we do have a pickup in . While I usually prefer to pick them up a little later I do not see a better option and ascend is strong build-around strategy.
Player’s Choice:
PICK 4
Petr Sochurek
Pick
If I took a I would snap of the , but as it is I would just take a good white 2 drop to go with the .
Sebastian Pozzo
Pick
Now we have to decide where are we going. sounds like the more reasonable choice. However I’m a big fan of decks, and pick 4 is late enough that we might see a and make a defensive ascend deck.
Kenji Tsumura
Pick
If you are not on the GW plan, is not that strong so not worth picking. At this moment, high chance that white might not be an open color, though no cards are here to change what we go for. I just pick the efficient 2 mana card.
Oliver Polak-Rottmann
Pick
, and are on par regarding powerlevel but I much rather stay on one color here.
Player’s Choice:
PICK 5
Petr Sochurek
Pick
Not sure what is the common opinion on this card, but the more I play with the set the more I like the chicken (as we called it in testing).
I think that it’s a premium white card and I would be happy to see it this late.
Sebastian Pozzo
Pick
Nothing too special. But if we attach to the idea of playing a defensive ascend deck this body is both great defense and a way to end games.
Kenji Tsumura
Pick
We see lots of white cards which I feel very relieved. looks ahead above the other cards in card power, though thinking what cards have passed, red doesn’t seem to look good. This makes me pick a card that does its job.
Oliver Polak-Rottmann
Pick
This is a great pickup for us. While I think this card is notoriously underrated it goes well in all ascend Strategies as it blocks every creature and chips in 2 damage every turn.
Player’s Choice:
PICK 6
Petr Sochurek
Pick
I don’t particularly like GW dinosaurs, that being said is by far the best card in the booster, so I would just take it even though I can still
see myself to draft UW or UG depending on how the rest of the draft goes.
Sebastian Pozzo
Pick
This is not a good defender but it’s a better finisher. I like picking one in pack one and try to grab a in pack 2 or even a in pack 3, remember we already have one and we would like to pick up more, so splashing shoulnd’t be a problem.
Kenji Tsumura
Pick
If we head for the GW build, we will want one or two copies of this card. If we are able to pick later on, picking would make a strong combo which I thought worth picking. Though my thoughts on is that it can be picked later in the draft which made my decision to pick first.
Oliver Polak-Rottmann
Pick
There is no white card to be found and it is the strongest card in the pack. All the tools we have so far match perfectly for GW dinosaurs, so I am happy with this pick.
Player’s Choice:
PICK 7
Petr Sochurek
Pick
I don’t really like the raptor, but it’s a 2 drop and I would take it here just in case I don’t see many 2 drops in the rest of the draft.
Sebastian Pozzo
Pick
The 4 drops are better, but we need to hold the early turns, and we want permanents that stay in the battlefield to cash all the that we can take in pack 2.
Kenji Tsumura
Pick
If we choose the second color to be blue,looks good. Though in our first packs, picking light mana cards leads to easier picks later on. This reasons me to pick which has a low mana cost and could cut off one less white card off the table.
Oliver Polak-Rottmann
Pick
While I rather draft UW than GW I make the safer pick in form of over . The is fine but way worse than I first thought.
Player’s Choice:
PICK 8
Petr Sochurek
Pick
I think that the remaining cards in my colors are fairly replacable, but picking up might potentially be very important.
Sebastian Pozzo
Pick
This is a late , I love that card. However I’m already commited to play a UW deffensive deck “Good old walls and flyers”. And gives the possibility to splash any bomb we might open.
Kenji Tsumura
Pick
I can’t believe this pack is at its eighth pick, though I will take which is a good combat trick.
Oliver Polak-Rottmann
Pick
This is a very interesting pick as it comes down to three cards: , and . Splashes in White decks happen quite regularly therefore would be a decent pickup. We don’t have a trick yet and we surely want 1-3 so is great. is interesting if we really go GW big dinosaurs but we don’t know that yet for sure. I would not blame anyone for picking any of the three cards but will go with here.
Player’s Choice:
The 8 Picks Together
Petr Sochurek
Sebastian Pozzo
Kenji Tsumura
Oliver Polak-Rottmann
Conclusion
The 4 players made the safer First Pick. But after that, they had the choice between stay of the same color (white) or try to read the signal and pick the most powerfull card. Both strategy have good and weak points. The thing is, force a color can make a perfect deck, or be disaster if player on your right are on the same one. You can’t be really sure after so few picks. If you pick different colors cards, You are assuming that you will not play some of them. You also send no signal to players on your left.
Thank you for reading,
Jeremy Dezani